Fake or Fortune? Catch up, Series 13: 5. What Happened Next? A Double Whodunnit on BBC 1

Fake or Fortune?

Series 13: 5. What Happened Next? A Double Whodunnit

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould revisit their 2017 investigation into two rare portraits of Black British women from the 18th and 19th centuries. Huge cultural shifts have happened since the original broadcast, with both paintings seeing their historical and commercial value soar and one of them finding a prestigious new home.\n\nThe original episode focuses on two remarkable paintings steeped in mystery – in both cases, the identity of the artist is unknown. The first artwork is a double portrait of Lady Elizabeth Murray and her cousin, Dido Belle, who was born into slavery and eventually became a member of the aristocratic Mansfield family. The painting is on display at Scone Palace in Scotland and was commissioned by the first Lord Mansfield, Dido Belle’s guardian, in the late 1770s or early 1780s, at the height of the transatlantic slave trade. In recent years, Belle’s incredible story has inspired books and a feature film about her life. Now, the current Lady Mansfield is determined to discover the name of the artist who painted her.\n\nThe second painting is even more unusual – two beautifully dressed girls holding a book in what appears to be a depiction of a tropical landscape. Early clues suggest this could be a political painting that is somehow connected to the campaign to abolish slavery in Britain’s colonies. Could the sitters themselves be enslaved? If so, why are they wearing such fine clothes? \n\nThe quest to solve both mysteries leads to renowned Scottish painter David Martin and pioneering artist Emma Jones, a child prodigy who made her name painting people on the margins of society. Demonstrating extraordinary skill and sophistication, both pictures are highly unusual in their positive depiction of Black women at a time when Britain was still heavily engaged in the transatlantic slave trade.\n\nIn the years since the episode was first broadcast, huge cultural shifts have taken place, inspired in part by the Black Lives Matter movement. Museums and galleries have raced to broaden the scope of the artworks in their collections, buying up the work of women artists and pictures that better reflect Britain’s multicultural history.\n\nPhilip and Fiona return to both paintings to find out what impact these changes have had on the value of the artworks and how they have enhanced their historical importance. They discover that the portrait of Dido Belle has become a star exhibit in multiple important exhibitions, while Two Girls with a Book, by Emma Jones, has found a new home, on loan to the Tate Gallery in London.

Source: BBC 1

Most recent episodes of Fake or Fortune?

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 14 : 5. What Happened Next? Toulouse-lautrec

Art detectives Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould revisit a story from Series 7, investigating two charming sketchbooks believed to be by Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec. Did owner Alain Br ...

19-08-2026

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 14: 4. Freud Or Fraud?

Art detectives Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould head to Somerset, where 15 unsigned prints of Lucian Freud’s etching Girl with Fig Leaf have been discovered in a garage. Will ...

08-08-2026

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 14: 3. The Last Gift

A French setting, a 20th-century artistic trailblazer, a tale of endurance and generosity – and a potentially huge price tag. \n\nArt sleuths Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould ...

01-08-2026

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 14: 2. A Passage To India

Two women lost in time: an enigmatic Indian woman and an 18th-century Scottish artist, both of whom, only now, are being rediscovered. \n\nFiona Bruce and Philip Mould embark on ...

23-07-2026

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 14: 1. Fabergé Or Fauxbergé

Did a delicate enamel Fabergé lily really find its way from Tsarist Russia to a shoebox in Liverpool? Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould are on the case, examining this mysteri ...

19-07-2026

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 12: 2. Helen Mcnicoll

Could a beautiful painting of women working in a field be a valuable lost work by Helen McNicoll, a celebrated impressionist artist from Canada? The quest to prove it takes the ...

22-10-2025

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 12: 1. Mondrian

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould investigate a charming little white flower picture, purported to be by one of the most important abstract artists of the 20th century, Piet Mondrian ...

15-10-2025

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 13: 6. What Happened Next? Helen Mcnicoll

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould return to the story of a beautiful painting by Canadian impressionist Helen McNicoll and find out what happens when owner David decides to offer the ...

01-09-2025

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 13: 5. What Happened Next? A Double Whodunnit

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould revisit their 2017 investigation into two rare portraits of Black British women from the 18th and 19th centuries. Huge cultural shifts have happened ...

24-08-2025

BBC 1

All episodes

Fake Or Fortune?

Series 13: 4. Portrait Of A Lady - In Pittsburgh?

In the suburbs of Pittsburgh, Fiona Bruce meets Laura and Pat, who purchased a painting of a young woman grieving over a funerary urn. It cost $200 from an estate auction, and i ...

21-08-2025

BBC 1

All episodes